Utility of pharmacists on clinical outcomes of patients in palliative care: A short review
Učinak farmaceuta na kliničke ishode kod pacijenata u palijativnoj nezi - kratak pregled
Apstrakt
Pharmacists as the most accessible health care professionals in outpatient settings can improve palliative patient care. The aim of this review was to assess utility of pharmacists (the effectiveness of pharmacists' interventions) on clinical outcomes of patients in palliative care at all levels of health care and in home care. Two electronic databases were searched: PubMed and SCOPUS (last searched August 2014). Primary studies, of any type of research design, in English, related to clinical outcomes of patients in palliative care and pharmacists' interventions were eligible. Studies that used surrogate outcome measures, such as number of pharmacists' recommendations were excluded. A total of 764 reports were found, and only three of them met our inclusion criteria. All of them assessed effects of pharmacists' interventions in outpatient settings and were case series. Symptoms improvement and stabilization of patients' conditions has been the main utility of pharmacists' interventions.... Assessed quality of two studies was moderate, and one study had low quality. As number of studies and quality of the evidence were limited, and results of reviewed studies indicate that pharmacists' interventions potentially could improve clinical outcomes of patients in palliative care, more research is needed to provide evidences in this field.
Farmaceuti, kao najdostupniji zdravstveni radnici u vanbolničkim uslovima, mogu unaprediti zdravstvenu zaštitu pacijenata u palijativnoj nezi. Cilj ovog pregleda bio je da se proceni učinak farmaceuta (efektivnost intervencija farmaceuta) na kliničke ishode kod pacijenata u palijativnoj nezi na svim nivoima zdravstvene zaštite i u kućnim uslovima. Pretražene su dve elektronske baze naučnih radova: PubMed i SCOPUS (poslednji put u avgustu 2014. godine). Uključeni su originalni naučni radovi na engleskom jeziku, bez obzira na dizajn studije, koji se odnose na kliničke ishode kod pacijenata u palijativnoj nezi i intervencije farmaceuta. Studije koje su koristile surogatne mere ishoda, kao što je broj preporuka farmaceuta, su isključene. Od inicijalno pronađena 764 rada, samo tri su zadovoljila kriterijume za uključivanje u pregled, i svi su se odnosili na intervencije farmaceuta u vanbolničkim uslovima. Sve 3 studije su bile prikazi studija slučajeva. U svim studijama intervencije farmace...uta su dovele do stabilazicije ili poboljšanja simptoma kod pacijenata. Procenjen kvalitet dve studije je bio srednji, a jedna studija je bila lošeg kvaliteta. Kako je broj studija i nivo dokaza ograničen, a rezultati studija ukazuju da intervencije farmaceuta potencijalno mogu imati pozitivan uticaj na kliničke ishode kod pacijenata u palijativnoj nezi, potrebna su dalja istraživanja u ovoj oblasti.
Ključne reči:
palliative care / pharmacists / clinical outcomes / palijativna nega / farmaceuti / klinički ishodiIzvor:
Arhiv za farmaciju, 2014, 64, 6, 487-498Izdavač:
- Savez farmaceutskih udruženja Srbije, Beograd
Finansiranje / projekti:
- Interakcije ksenobiotika i uticaj na sisteme u biomedicini (RS-41012)
- Retke bolesti: molekularna patofiziologija, dijagnostički i terapijski modaliteti i socijalni, etički i pravni aspekti (RS-41004)
Institucija/grupa
PharmacyTY - JOUR AU - Brkić, Jovana AU - Tasić, Ljiljana AU - Krajnović, Dušanka PY - 2014 UR - https://farfar.pharmacy.bg.ac.rs/handle/123456789/2296 AB - Pharmacists as the most accessible health care professionals in outpatient settings can improve palliative patient care. The aim of this review was to assess utility of pharmacists (the effectiveness of pharmacists' interventions) on clinical outcomes of patients in palliative care at all levels of health care and in home care. Two electronic databases were searched: PubMed and SCOPUS (last searched August 2014). Primary studies, of any type of research design, in English, related to clinical outcomes of patients in palliative care and pharmacists' interventions were eligible. Studies that used surrogate outcome measures, such as number of pharmacists' recommendations were excluded. A total of 764 reports were found, and only three of them met our inclusion criteria. All of them assessed effects of pharmacists' interventions in outpatient settings and were case series. Symptoms improvement and stabilization of patients' conditions has been the main utility of pharmacists' interventions. Assessed quality of two studies was moderate, and one study had low quality. As number of studies and quality of the evidence were limited, and results of reviewed studies indicate that pharmacists' interventions potentially could improve clinical outcomes of patients in palliative care, more research is needed to provide evidences in this field. AB - Farmaceuti, kao najdostupniji zdravstveni radnici u vanbolničkim uslovima, mogu unaprediti zdravstvenu zaštitu pacijenata u palijativnoj nezi. Cilj ovog pregleda bio je da se proceni učinak farmaceuta (efektivnost intervencija farmaceuta) na kliničke ishode kod pacijenata u palijativnoj nezi na svim nivoima zdravstvene zaštite i u kućnim uslovima. Pretražene su dve elektronske baze naučnih radova: PubMed i SCOPUS (poslednji put u avgustu 2014. godine). Uključeni su originalni naučni radovi na engleskom jeziku, bez obzira na dizajn studije, koji se odnose na kliničke ishode kod pacijenata u palijativnoj nezi i intervencije farmaceuta. Studije koje su koristile surogatne mere ishoda, kao što je broj preporuka farmaceuta, su isključene. Od inicijalno pronađena 764 rada, samo tri su zadovoljila kriterijume za uključivanje u pregled, i svi su se odnosili na intervencije farmaceuta u vanbolničkim uslovima. Sve 3 studije su bile prikazi studija slučajeva. U svim studijama intervencije farmaceuta su dovele do stabilazicije ili poboljšanja simptoma kod pacijenata. Procenjen kvalitet dve studije je bio srednji, a jedna studija je bila lošeg kvaliteta. Kako je broj studija i nivo dokaza ograničen, a rezultati studija ukazuju da intervencije farmaceuta potencijalno mogu imati pozitivan uticaj na kliničke ishode kod pacijenata u palijativnoj nezi, potrebna su dalja istraživanja u ovoj oblasti. PB - Savez farmaceutskih udruženja Srbije, Beograd T2 - Arhiv za farmaciju T1 - Utility of pharmacists on clinical outcomes of patients in palliative care: A short review T1 - Učinak farmaceuta na kliničke ishode kod pacijenata u palijativnoj nezi - kratak pregled VL - 64 IS - 6 SP - 487 EP - 498 DO - 10.5937/arhfarm1406487B ER -
@article{ author = "Brkić, Jovana and Tasić, Ljiljana and Krajnović, Dušanka", year = "2014", abstract = "Pharmacists as the most accessible health care professionals in outpatient settings can improve palliative patient care. The aim of this review was to assess utility of pharmacists (the effectiveness of pharmacists' interventions) on clinical outcomes of patients in palliative care at all levels of health care and in home care. Two electronic databases were searched: PubMed and SCOPUS (last searched August 2014). Primary studies, of any type of research design, in English, related to clinical outcomes of patients in palliative care and pharmacists' interventions were eligible. Studies that used surrogate outcome measures, such as number of pharmacists' recommendations were excluded. A total of 764 reports were found, and only three of them met our inclusion criteria. All of them assessed effects of pharmacists' interventions in outpatient settings and were case series. Symptoms improvement and stabilization of patients' conditions has been the main utility of pharmacists' interventions. Assessed quality of two studies was moderate, and one study had low quality. As number of studies and quality of the evidence were limited, and results of reviewed studies indicate that pharmacists' interventions potentially could improve clinical outcomes of patients in palliative care, more research is needed to provide evidences in this field., Farmaceuti, kao najdostupniji zdravstveni radnici u vanbolničkim uslovima, mogu unaprediti zdravstvenu zaštitu pacijenata u palijativnoj nezi. Cilj ovog pregleda bio je da se proceni učinak farmaceuta (efektivnost intervencija farmaceuta) na kliničke ishode kod pacijenata u palijativnoj nezi na svim nivoima zdravstvene zaštite i u kućnim uslovima. Pretražene su dve elektronske baze naučnih radova: PubMed i SCOPUS (poslednji put u avgustu 2014. godine). Uključeni su originalni naučni radovi na engleskom jeziku, bez obzira na dizajn studije, koji se odnose na kliničke ishode kod pacijenata u palijativnoj nezi i intervencije farmaceuta. Studije koje su koristile surogatne mere ishoda, kao što je broj preporuka farmaceuta, su isključene. Od inicijalno pronađena 764 rada, samo tri su zadovoljila kriterijume za uključivanje u pregled, i svi su se odnosili na intervencije farmaceuta u vanbolničkim uslovima. Sve 3 studije su bile prikazi studija slučajeva. U svim studijama intervencije farmaceuta su dovele do stabilazicije ili poboljšanja simptoma kod pacijenata. Procenjen kvalitet dve studije je bio srednji, a jedna studija je bila lošeg kvaliteta. Kako je broj studija i nivo dokaza ograničen, a rezultati studija ukazuju da intervencije farmaceuta potencijalno mogu imati pozitivan uticaj na kliničke ishode kod pacijenata u palijativnoj nezi, potrebna su dalja istraživanja u ovoj oblasti.", publisher = "Savez farmaceutskih udruženja Srbije, Beograd", journal = "Arhiv za farmaciju", title = "Utility of pharmacists on clinical outcomes of patients in palliative care: A short review, Učinak farmaceuta na kliničke ishode kod pacijenata u palijativnoj nezi - kratak pregled", volume = "64", number = "6", pages = "487-498", doi = "10.5937/arhfarm1406487B" }
Brkić, J., Tasić, L.,& Krajnović, D.. (2014). Utility of pharmacists on clinical outcomes of patients in palliative care: A short review. in Arhiv za farmaciju Savez farmaceutskih udruženja Srbije, Beograd., 64(6), 487-498. https://doi.org/10.5937/arhfarm1406487B
Brkić J, Tasić L, Krajnović D. Utility of pharmacists on clinical outcomes of patients in palliative care: A short review. in Arhiv za farmaciju. 2014;64(6):487-498. doi:10.5937/arhfarm1406487B .
Brkić, Jovana, Tasić, Ljiljana, Krajnović, Dušanka, "Utility of pharmacists on clinical outcomes of patients in palliative care: A short review" in Arhiv za farmaciju, 64, no. 6 (2014):487-498, https://doi.org/10.5937/arhfarm1406487B . .